An 11-part series on the progress, promise and potential challenges of community engagement in journalism inspired by Experience Engagement.
Author: Journalism That Matters
Creating communities of practice: Visual maps by Nitya Wakhlu
On Sunday — the final day of the conference — graphic facilitator Nitya Wakhlu recorded key concepts related to Experience Engagement and creating communities of practice.
As Nitya explains on her website:
As a graphic facilitator, Nitya brings a ninja-like listening ability to the table. She distills what she hears and creates a large-scale mural of key insights and emerging conversation patterns. She does this using images, words, connectors and colorful cartoons. This live visual capture prevents precious insight from being lost, stimulates higher levels of group creativity and helps the group truly “see the big picture”.
Graphic recording happening live at #pdxEngage15 @sojcagora. Cool approach! pic.twitter.com/6gNfCjXwVM
— SPO Visual Story (@SPO_VisualStory) October 4, 2015
What a #joy to have a great #visual #artist – Nitya Wakhlu – weaving our #conversations at #pdxengage15 @jtmstream pic.twitter.com/jO0F1dQbws
— ssilha (@ssilha) October 4, 2015
Here are the final products of Nitya’s documentation (click to enlarge):
Conference livesketches by Dan Archer, graphic journalist
Dan Archer, graphic journalist and director of Empathetic Media, joined us in Portland for Experience Engagement and created some amazing livesketches of conference sessions and workshops.
Read on for the story and to see the sketches as they unfolded:
So psyched to have @Empatheticmedia @archcomix attending, illustrating #pdxengage15 #pdxlisteningpost http://t.co/yfFLgyHXnG
— lindakaymiller (@linda_pinsight) September 25, 2015
Listening vs. Interviewing: incorporating empathy into the journalistic process feat @andrewhaeg #pdxengage15 pic.twitter.com/tidIaQSxbc
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
Analyzing the issue at #PDXengage15 with @RMSpeaks @amberwaves14 @AshleyAlvarado pic.twitter.com/pGHgoVWZcn
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
Designing @archcomix0 listening posts before putting them in public @archcomix1 #PDXengage15 pic.twitter.com/30SRE7Yi9V
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
.@AshleyAlvarado and Jill Hopkins sharing feedback from the live listening post experience @archcomix2 pic.twitter.com/MNnH7es8NT
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
Applying a Kaleidoscope approach to pry spaces in engagement strategies with problematic Qs @archcomix3 #pdxengage15 pic.twitter.com/DI6acfZqAN
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 2, 2015
#Livesketch of last night’s final Kaleidoscope session, bring on today’s Breakout sessions! @archcomix2 pic.twitter.com/TcVWjdqSWD
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 2, 2015
Fascinated with the style that @archcomix captured notes at @archcomix0. Evening collaborations ensued https://t.co/dN8STVhDRO
— SPO Visual Story (@SPO_VisualStory) October 4, 2015
We’ve created a Facebook photo album to display some of the great illustrations @archcomix is doing of #PDXengage15 https://t.co/hVThsMyePe
— Journalism T Matters (@jtmstream) October 2, 2015
.@archcomix is illustrating #pdxEngage15. So impressive. pic.twitter.com/TU1H1ypsBu
— Ashley Alvarado (@AshleyAlvarado) October 1, 2015
Opening session from #PDXengage15 feat. @linda_pinsight @andrewhaeg @AshleyAlvarado asking what listening looks like pic.twitter.com/1h5WRhQMST
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
Discussing @archcomix1 pic.twitter.com/ryN6VVCc36
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
Are smart phones ruining your relationships? Portlanders tell @archcomix2 #PDXengage15 @archcomix3 pic.twitter.com/DKxDQDJUR6
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
Opening remarks from @archcomix3 and @archcomix4 at #PDXengage15 #livesketch. @archcomix3 pic.twitter.com/MchSopXJ5T
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 1, 2015
#Livesketch of last night’s final Kaleidoscope session, bring on today’s Breakout sessions! @archcomix2 pic.twitter.com/TcVWjdqSWD
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 2, 2015
POV, curation, social capital- services journalists sell & need readers to value/ fund @archcomix5 pic.twitter.com/8r3FTOz9YI
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 3, 2015
Some of the fruit of a productive few days of listening & conversation at @archcomix2 thx @archcomix6 ! pic.twitter.com/xmsh0NjZX4
— Dan Archer (@archcomix) October 5, 2015
Thirty Five: What’s a key idea that guides your engagement work?
At Experiencing Engagement on Friday afternoon, we used an exercise called “Thirty Five” — involving 3×5 index cards — to bubble up key words and phrases most important to participants. The way it worked: People wrote a word or phrase on a card. Then we circulated and passed cards. Each pair of people discussed the two cards they held, and wrote on the back two nmbers — one on each card — which together numerically totaled seven. Then we circulated and did this again — five times. Eventually each card had a set of numbers on the back, ranging from 0 to 7. Summing the numbers “ranked” each card — and the phrase on it. Here’s background on this debriefing “game”:
http://www.thiagi.com/archived-games/2015/2/22/thirty-five-for-debriefing
Here’s what we came up with:
25 Reciprocity
25 Elevate authentic voices
24 It’s to be honest, authentic and true with those I’m working with, to follow through on promises so trust can be built because without that quality everything falls apart
24 Desire to go beyond “two sides” of the issue
23 Build bridges between empathy (personal interest stories, arts expression, local connections) and data (context, backstory, facts, charts) as well as “action” (more from consumer to doer)
23 Empathy, building to create connection to create a more compassoinate world
22 Work with those most affect, not those who claim to represent them
22 Don’t work alone; invest in relationships as much mor more than products
22 Engagement is partly about sharing control and ownership
21 is the person in front of me (or on the line) feeling like he/she/they have been listened to?
21 We need our engagement work to be more intentional — with planning, someone to shepard it, and ways to evaluate the success of the effort
21 Honesty about where we are and where we want to go
21 Empowerment
21 Openness (to new perspectives, ideas, partnerships, etc. etc.)
20 Inclusion — finding unpopular and unheard voices
20 Listen from the ground up
20 Trust built over time
20 Context
20 Meet people where they area, not where I want them to be
20 Accountability
19.5 Curiousity
19 Caring
19 Authenticity, going deep
19 Mutual respect
19 Meaning / trust / dialogue
19 Humility
19 Trust: Without trust, engagement is at best incomplete and at worst non-existent or even toxic. We live in untrustworthy times, so we need better models.
19 Understanding
19 Exposure to and appreciation of diverse political views
18.5 Community of subscribers and loyal supporters speak to us all the time / inclusion
18 Who benefits
18 Connecting
18 Inclusiveness
18 Listening to understand, not explain
18 Transparency equals (?) honesty
18 Connectivity
18 Work with, not for, people
18 Authentic
17.5 Listening / empathy
17 Integrity
17 Authentic collaboration
17 People need to feel hurt
17 Storytelling
17 Solution based
17 Know thyself beyond all things in order to be fully available for others. Practice seeing every person in their full dignity, without labels, without diminishing thjem.
17 Engagement is worthwhile for everyone involved — everyone gets something from it
17 Holding the space for engagement
17 Inclusion
17 Open heart and mind
16 Do what you can to allow stories to flow between people — the shortest distance between two people is a story
16 Someone in the “audience” knows much more about any subject than we as journalists
16 Supporting self determination
16 Compassion
15 Carve out time to collaborate without distractions
14 Buy in from the newsroom
14 Residents: Connecting I to us.
14 Democracy
14 All opinions matter
13.5 Synthesis
13 Trustworthy engagement
13 Justice: Bedrock value that informs my engagement.
13 That I am not doing enough of the right type of engagement
12.5 Engagement is about redefining the role of media so that our resources and expertise continue to have value for readers
12 Remember the people
12 To be useful
11 Authenticity
10 People already know what needs to be done; I’d like to give people a tool to do that
10 Not being contained by speed but pay attention to practicality
9 Rawness
Portland Marathon: A Sunday morning traffic snarl
The run will start down at SW 4th/ Salmon at 7 AM. They run north to Couch and then to Naito. So the westbound traffic across the Burnside and Morrison bridges are held until the full event gets moving down Couch. These points will reopen by 7:45. The Steel Bridge will be unaffected during the event.
The runners come back down Couch to Naito at the end of the event. So, either:
Access the area south of Couch via the Burnside/Morrison bridges after the event start and park south of the location in any of the downtown parking garages/lots that are not on Couch, Naito, or in the formation area.
Access the area north of the route via the Steel Bridge and park in one of the Old Town/Pearl lots north of the location and walk across the event route on Couch. The Smart Park across the street on NW Davis will be available.